What Works
A discussion is going on over at the Nocturne thread at eharlequin, but you don't need to rush over there to get the background stuff for this blog post. In fact, it's the same discussion repeated, countlessly, on many a writer blog.
There is a whole contingency of writers who have a "page per day" goal. And that's great. Some of them post little meters on their blog to chart their progress--also great. In fact, I know precisely which of you blog readers, among my regular pals, falls into that category--and I love ya! But in the end, we tend to applaud that which we admire. And there is a risk, sometimes I think, especially with NaNoWriMo starting soon, to focus on schedules and so on, to the point of calling us schedule-less fools "scattered." Or disorganized. Or whatever.
Now, the thing is, we do revere what it is we like in ourselves very often. Case in point: Parent-teacher conferences. Two of my four kids are messy. One is exceedingly neat. One is 18 months old so he's a cyclone. But my two messy kids, when I would visit their classrooms, had teachers who made a special point of showing me how they didn't (in one case) keep their pencils the way they were supposed to. "They are supposed to line them up over here and . . . . and . . . ." And so the lessons of organization were being taught. BUT, here's the thing. At no point, did the teachers ever pause and say, "Have you ever seen your son's comics? [side note: They are AMAZING!] Have you ever seen what he writes? Have you ever heard your daughter's musical abilities?" The creative things don't fit in the round hole. So square pegs . . . well, not so applauded by the "system."
I don't begrudge the teachers and their lined-up pencils. It's a way to be. One way. I used to, when I was a younger, more passionate version of myself, come home muttering things like "Anal-retentive b****." But that's because what I applauded and lauded was creativity. One of my children drew an entire mural on a wall. I gave her the "we draw on paper, not walls" speech, but I had to admit, even to her, the scale of it was pretty amazing for a four-year-old. Then she drew a similar scene, complete with mountains and hikers and ski chalets, on my couch. My solution wasn't to freak but to think, "It is not my destiny, right now, to own expensive furniture."
Anyway, scattered, chaotic, disorganized, whatever . . . I don't think there's anything inherently wrong with my way of doing things. I've sold 25+ novels and I am still thriving. I love what I do. Yes, it's sometimes flying blind, winging it, whatever. And no, I cannot tell you week to week how many pages I write--or even if I've written ANY pages.
The point of this post is simply, as writers across the blogosphere gear up for NaNoWriMo, to say . . . you know there is a place for you as a writer if you don't follow a schedule, don't stay in the lines, if your pencils don't line up, if you have four kids, three dogs, a parrot, a python, and murals on your couch. If you can't commit to a schedule because you just never know what the day will bring. There is a place for you. You can STILL be a writer.
So . . . just applauding our differences. This is what works for me. What works for you?
There is a whole contingency of writers who have a "page per day" goal. And that's great. Some of them post little meters on their blog to chart their progress--also great. In fact, I know precisely which of you blog readers, among my regular pals, falls into that category--and I love ya! But in the end, we tend to applaud that which we admire. And there is a risk, sometimes I think, especially with NaNoWriMo starting soon, to focus on schedules and so on, to the point of calling us schedule-less fools "scattered." Or disorganized. Or whatever.
Now, the thing is, we do revere what it is we like in ourselves very often. Case in point: Parent-teacher conferences. Two of my four kids are messy. One is exceedingly neat. One is 18 months old so he's a cyclone. But my two messy kids, when I would visit their classrooms, had teachers who made a special point of showing me how they didn't (in one case) keep their pencils the way they were supposed to. "They are supposed to line them up over here and . . . . and . . . ." And so the lessons of organization were being taught. BUT, here's the thing. At no point, did the teachers ever pause and say, "Have you ever seen your son's comics? [side note: They are AMAZING!] Have you ever seen what he writes? Have you ever heard your daughter's musical abilities?" The creative things don't fit in the round hole. So square pegs . . . well, not so applauded by the "system."
I don't begrudge the teachers and their lined-up pencils. It's a way to be. One way. I used to, when I was a younger, more passionate version of myself, come home muttering things like "Anal-retentive b****." But that's because what I applauded and lauded was creativity. One of my children drew an entire mural on a wall. I gave her the "we draw on paper, not walls" speech, but I had to admit, even to her, the scale of it was pretty amazing for a four-year-old. Then she drew a similar scene, complete with mountains and hikers and ski chalets, on my couch. My solution wasn't to freak but to think, "It is not my destiny, right now, to own expensive furniture."
Anyway, scattered, chaotic, disorganized, whatever . . . I don't think there's anything inherently wrong with my way of doing things. I've sold 25+ novels and I am still thriving. I love what I do. Yes, it's sometimes flying blind, winging it, whatever. And no, I cannot tell you week to week how many pages I write--or even if I've written ANY pages.
The point of this post is simply, as writers across the blogosphere gear up for NaNoWriMo, to say . . . you know there is a place for you as a writer if you don't follow a schedule, don't stay in the lines, if your pencils don't line up, if you have four kids, three dogs, a parrot, a python, and murals on your couch. If you can't commit to a schedule because you just never know what the day will bring. There is a place for you. You can STILL be a writer.
So . . . just applauding our differences. This is what works for me. What works for you?


30 Comments:
Parent/teacher conferences. Ack! We have a guy who has worked for us 8 yrs. He's 6'7 and all the best that hours of gym time can offer. When my kids were little, my dh used to joke that he was going to send Rob with me to the conferences...to hold me back and protect the teachers!
Don't get me wrong, I'm not slamming teachers. Honest. But I think because they work within such a regimented profession, they often tend to be the type of people who believe there is only one way to do things.
My dd is a freakin cyclone. And I got so sick of hearing things like 'poor time management' and 'her own worst enemy b/c of her disorganization' How 'bout 'jeez, amazing the kid can pull off these great marks despite the fact that her desk looks like a recycle bin?'
The neat freak boy had a teacher concerned b/c he was too competitive, an over achiever. WTF?
They are who they are, and its your JOB to encourage their strengths. Not turn them in to clones.
On a writer note. Never give myself a page limit. Its like an invitation to get nothing done. I've tried and I get so distracted by the page #/wrd ct, I can't even think any more. Guess there's a tiny part of me that will never out grow that 'you can't make me' disorder, but the minute I think 'drop and give me 10 pages' something inside me goes, 'hmm, think its time to walk the dogs' :P
There's absolutely no "right way" to write. Just so long as words make the page, it's all good. :)
Me, I usually write with a goal for each day, but lately...well, it's more of a "feel it out" approach.
Oh. Hmm. I might be the only one here who's still in school, so...
I think teachers naturally prefer square pegs. I understand why they do, but I'm not one.
The thing is, I'm outwardly a square peg. A good square peg, at that--you know, quiet, 'diligent' etc. If I was a student in your class, you'd probably say I'm a plotter, not a pantzer.
Well, these teachers don't know that my assignments are typically done at the last minute, for instance. Or that I never ever pack my bag at night.
I've done the schedule thing, though most of the time I don't have one. I'm undecided whether I'll have one for NaNo.
Erica,
I read this and it took me back 32 years ago when my then 7 daughter was having anxiety problems all of a sudden.
You start in the school...well it boiled down to that her "teacher" was a frilly/lacey type woman with no imagination.
You see, my eledest daughter was not into dolls or tea parties. She was sloppy and marched to her own drummer.
Our conference with her teacher was certainly illuminating..."Mr and Mrs. D...your daughter's reading interest leans towards the macabre " We say "please explain"???? Teacher says "she likes to read about dinosaurs and lizard and gangsters...and NOT things that the OTHER little girls like to read....like...like...fairy tales!"
Well we left the meeting..shaking our head and going home and telling our 7 year old to continue with her pleasures whatever they may be.
Today, my eldest is immersed in education. She was a teacher for many years before going on to administration. She has two Master's degree's and is on her way to receive her Ed.D (Ph.d in education).
Again....I am not a writer but I find your interests and comments very inspiring. Wish that I had seen your take on this 32 years ago.
By the way...each of my daughter's were very different...eldest..threw her pencils in a desk....the younger one..that you know lined them up by color all in a row and they even matched what she was wearing for the day. Ok not really ...but close. Funny as time would have it..they both are very creative women..still with the same differences as when they were children...and like you...I think that is just wonderful.
~S.
Erica, I'm a panser which says a great deal. lol. If it's sunny out and I feel like it, I go play. Especially if I get a call from one of my grandbabies! I worked for years at the day job, wrote furiously evenings and weekends. Like most writers do. Now, I have my days to write and, I do, but my rhythm. It's all good. And I agree, children are amazing. I'm thrilled you see the beauty in each of your children. They teach us so much about life.
Hi Lainey:
I think when we approach anyone, it's our job to see their strengths and build on them, whether we are a boss, manager, parent, teacher . . .
As for writing . . . I don't know what it is about page goals that doesn't work for me. I think it's because I will always do a mental calculation--"Oh, I didn't write for two days, but I can write 10 pages today and make up for that." I just find life intrudes too much to stick to it completely.
E
Heather:
Great point. It's an amorphous thing that is one way for one writer, and another for a different person.
E
May:
Me, too. I could do things on the fly--especially essays--and they would sound like I had actually spent a great deal of time on them in school.
E
Sandra:
You sound like a great mom! My parents didn't do a lot to encourage creativity, I think because my father was the first person in his family to graduate from college--and he did that as an adult--and so education was very important to him and was his view of how we would succeed in life--which if you are going to get straight As as a child means staying in the lines.
And I know there are people who hate the way schools applaud diversity now, but your example is wonderful. I mean, teachers don't AS MUCH as they used to, see gender roles and so on. Some of that bias has been blurred. I can't even imagine if I was confronted by someone saying that about my kids' reading choices.
E
ladonna:
If you have a lot of children and a busy house, the household is a living being. It's a system, an organism, whatever analogy you want to use. So, that being the case . . . you have to respect its breathing and living patterns--which means knowing sometimes the rhythm will allow you to work--and sometimes not.
E
Erica, I think you're awesome for posting this.
I've always felt it very important that authors share their methods of ANY type (or lack thereof!) precisely because we need to hear how diverse we are, and both know it's okay to do it our way...or maybe learn a better way for us.
I have been incredibly blessed with my kids' educators. I am always prepared for situations like those described here, but have never run into any. When my oldest was finishing 3rd grade, her gifted support teacher and regular teacher raved about how she wore a Renaissance Faire dress to school, just because she wanted to, and how much they appreciated her individuality. My youngest is gifted at math, and rarely does her calculations the way she's "supposed" to. They allow her to do things the way her mind works, and I'm so grateful.
I just had to share that there ARE teachers out there who care more about the kids than about the boxes they want to put them in. :) I wish it could be that way everywhere.
Erica,
I have a parent-teacher conference today!
My child's super creative too, but she's got a cool teacher this year so I think we'll be okay. I'm keeping my finger's crossed she never gets a teacher like my sister's.
As for your question:
About the most I do for scheduling is aim for a chapter a day or a week depending on what's going on in my life.
Yes, like Mom showed you, I do like order, but with a life probably as hectic as yours, sometimes you just have to give up the ghost.
If you look close you can see the mural one of mine made all along my the kitchen, up the stairs and in the bedrooms.
What was I doing?
Writing!
My couches are dark leather for a reason!
:) d
Well, I'm the messy and disorganized one in my family. I work well from a list if only just to keep me focused. I've tried to write from an outline, and I continue to try, but I always get caught up in the story and then find myself way off of my original storyline. I usually just run with it.
Both of my children are creative, but one is very concerned with doing it "right", while the other compulsively disregards convention. I love them both although I understand the compulsive one a bit more.
As a child I was to afraid of doing the wrong thing and so I made myself conform to the square peg format. It has taken all of my life to overcome that fear... and I still suffer from bouts of it.
Thanks for another great thought provoking post.
Great post, Erica!
I've tried to do the Nano thing, admire it big time, but it just doesn't work for me. I similarly admire those folks who can map out their daily schedule and have it work out just the way they planned.
Alas, I cannot walk that neat and orderly path, though I have tried. I do a lot better embracing the chaos that is my life, rather than trying to overpower it or subdue it.
I tend to write in furious bursts. I keep thinking it's more noble and less crazymaking to write to a schedule, from a detailed outline. But I do a lot better letting the stories grab me when they are ready to get written -- I write fast when I'm deep into it, and go fallow the rest of the time.
I used to think this haphazard way of writing was a weakness. But when I let the stories have their way with me, they dictate what comes, and the quality of the writing is much better.
That said, I keep limber by at least trying to write every day I can...a "routine" if not a schedule. But after I finish a big project, I'm dry as a bone. It takes me at least a couple of weeks off before I can get back on the writing horsey again.
Again, thanks for the thought-provoking (and deeply reassuring!) post :-)
Michele
Erica, I've heard it called circular and linear.
Did you know you're in the same category as Stephen King? He sort of has a beginning and an end, the fills in the circle, getting to the end, however he gets to the end.
I so ENVY you! Because I'm linear. Step 1, to 2, to 3, etc. I tangent and circle, and get so, so lost if I don't have some sort of map.
The type of diagram that you mentioned in another post sounds like a mind-map. All those lines boggle my mind and make me cross-eyed, let alone feel as if my head is going to implode.
The charts, the sheets, the sketches, the guides--yes sometimes they're helpful. Setting aside time to write within my work schedule is helpful. But at some point, linear tranforms into anal and I end up being buired beneath the strategies and structure and what were intended to be helpful tools.
Again, sigh...I envy you.
I'm sure sooner or later I'll have some kind of process. But I don't yet. I have parent/teacher conferences soon. I'm so proud of my daughter who has made the merit roll this quarter.
I think the thing I"ve had the hardest time dealing with is that I used to set writing goals and BEAT them and now I struggle because writing and life changes. I have no choice but to set goals right now because I have a deadline.
I was a lot like Ewoh as a child and I see a lot of that in my oldest child. He's very into black/white/right/wrong/getting the right answer...there's no room for abstract thinking or creativity with him (he's also the one that asks quesitons all through movies and tv shows and I have to say "just watch!" Gaaaaaaaa). He's turned away from reading right now too but that's okay. Funny enough he's the leftie who's good at math with some artistic talents.
The other kid? Remember pigpen from Peanuts? Remember the kid that came to school looking like he'd just rolled out of bed? Yeah that's my #2 son.
I've accepted (and love!) the fact that even though the kids will change (some) they are who and what they are.
What was the question again?
Natalie:
Well, the reason I posted this to begin with was there is definitely a tendency with one or two bloggers whose blogs I have visited but not posted on (thus taking yours out of the running--LOL!) where the author pontificates. This is the "right way" or the best way or the most organizaed way . . . this is the correct path to publication, this or that won't get you there.
It's a crapshoot. And whatever works, works.
And . . . this year my younger daughter has a FAB teacher full of creativity. I'm thrilled. My son? not so lucky.
E
Dana:
Your comment made me laugh. I have had more minor calamities in my house because I was . . . writing! And not fully present while my kids made milkshakes in the blender without the lid or whatever.
E
Ewoh:
I skipped grades at school--so I was able to perform super well academically, but I was always out of step. The consequence was an attempt to do it "the right way." But an internal feeling of being lost and lonely and sad all the time. In my twenties, I started to blossom. When I left my first marriage which was stifling and abusive in many ways, I REALLY blossomed. And now there is simply no shutting me up. And no conformity. :-)
E
Michele:
Furious bursts so perfectly--I mean PERFECTLY--describes my writing style!
THANKS!
E
Kathy:
Thank you so much for sharing that information. Yes, that's very much how I work--nice to know I am in such best-selling company!
E
la:
When you write the way I do, you don't think you have a process either. But then when you step back, you realize that you actually do. It just isn't a neat orderly process like everyone else's--though apparently by the comments here, there are more of us chaotic souls than those outliners would have us believe. LOL!
E
Amie:
I think one of the realities of combining parenting and writing, or an intense day job with trying to break into writing, or ANY situation where you have a conflict between needing and wanting to write and "real life" interfering, is the process must bend and change and the old ways of setting more rigid goals become more fluid.
Good luck on your deadline.
E
You're absolutely right, Erica. There's no right or wrong way to write.
JA Konrath waits until 30 days before deadline and then writes like a madman.
Stephen King--though he doesn't outline--is actually a fairly regimented soul. When he's working on something, he writes at least 2000 words a day whether it's Christmas or his birthday or whatever.
Dean Koontz is such a perfectionist, he rewrites everything over and over until he feels it's just right. His method yields about three pages a day. But they're damn good pages!
If I'm ever fortunate enough to ditch my weekend astronaut job, I'll be able to get into a more organized routine. As it is, I write as much as I can on my days off and try not to worry too much about word count. I have no desire to participate in that Nanu Nanu thing, whatever it's called, because I know if I tried to produce a novel in thirty days it would be pure crap and I don't want to waste my time writing crap.
Sorry, but I laughed out loud about the mural on the couch. :) Great post!
Erica,
Since I started this--lol let me just say THANK YOU.
My mother is that same anal retentive beotch you spoke about. I love her dearly, but man, there were days growing up when a little freedom to be creative would've been nice. If we left one toy to go get something else, she was yelling for us to pick it up. Everything had to be in its place and neat, not scattered and I think I rebelled to the point where I'm scattered.
Like Lainey, if I give myself a page amount, I ultimately fail. Same with doing Nano or any other book in a week, month, day thing. I open up word and stare at the empty page and my muse flies someplace else.
I'm glad that I'm allowed to be who I am and what works for me--it's just the days when it doesn't work for me that drive me up the wall. I'm a panster, I can only plot so much before I get bored. I love not knowing where the characters are going to take me. Some people might think that's wrong, but the other way doesn't work for me as a writer.
I know I have a lot to learn yet and I embrace it. On the same token, I wish when my muse hit, that the rest of the people in my house would cooperate. But this is life.
Thank you for your wonderful advice. As always.
Rae
Hi Rae;
I think there's just a sense of, if you ask, "What are your tips for being less scattered" that there is something inherenetly broken that must be fixed. So 0my post was really to say we scattered gals and guys are okay, too! :-)
E
where the author pontificates. This is the "right way" or the best way or the most organizaed way . . .
Oh, I know, and I HATE it! Especially when it's someone really big-name and successful and they allow NO flexibility or any chance that they are WRONG. They can do harm to a lot of people.
Hi natalie:
I totally agree. I always say the way I do it is a mess, but "it works for me"--and consider anyone else's pattern of writing, if it works for them, to be totally fine. Obviously, if it isn't working for you, you might want to try something new . . . but until then . . .
E
tibia money tibia gold tibia item runescape money runescape gold runescape power leveling tibia gold runescape money runescape gold runescape accounts runescape gp runescape power leveling dofus kamas buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape items tibia item runescape accounts runescape gp wow power leveling wow powerleveling Warcraft PowerLeveling tibia money tibia gold runescape powerleveling buy dofus kamas Warcraft Power Leveling World of Warcraft PowerLeveling World of Warcraft Power Leveling Hellgate money Hellgate gold Guild Wars Gold buy Guild Wars Gold lotro gold buy lotro gold Hellgate Palladium Hellgate London Palladium Hellgate London gold runescape money runescape gold eve isk eve online isk Fiesta Silver Fiesta Gold SilkRoad Gold buy SilkRoad Gold Scions of Fate Gold SOF Gold Age Of Conan Gold AOC Gold lotro gold buy lotro gold buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape items ArchLord gold buy ArchLord gold DDO Plat tibia money tibia gold tibia item Dungeons and Dragons Online Plat
Post a Comment
<< Home