The Allure of Evil

I watched The Departed last night, and some of the funniest lines were spouted by the bad guys.
How's your mother?
She's on her way out.
We all are. Act accordingly.
How's your mother?
She's on her way out.
We all are. Act accordingly.
F*ck yourself, you piece of sh*t.
And I need the identities of your undercovers.
Blow me. Not literally, though, unfortunately there's no promotion involved.
I laughed out loud. And that, is the allure of evil.
I had more than one reader tell me that they were bothered by how much they liked Uncle Two in The Roofer. Or even Frank. They're murderers. No questions asked, no guilty consciences. But they're loyal guys with totally sick, dark senses of humor--senses of humor that I share.
But does that mean I am glorifying violence? It's a question asked every time Scorsese makes a film. It was a question asked about The Godfather trilogy. It's asked about The Sopranos. And as I work on The Devil's Agents, it's something people COULD ask. But I don't. I never wonder whether I am glorifying violence. Because I'm not. I'm merely depicting it in full, round detail.
Evil is alluring. It's that simple. If it wasn't, people wouldn't sin, if you want to get all Biblical about it. Having an affair--easier than working on a marriage. Taking drugs--easier than facing your problems. Killing your estranged wife--easier than getting a divorce. At first. That's how evil sucks you in. Then it gets hard and twisted and difficult. But first . . . it has to be alluring.
Bad guys can be funny. They can be daddies. Not fathers, but dear, sweet, wonderful daddies who pick their little girls up and twirl them in an "airplane." They make sacrfices for their families sometimes--families they adore. They kiss their wives. They make love. They sit down and say grace around the dinner table. And they also kill without much thought. THAT is the reality of some gangsters. And if you play it that they don't have the humor and the allure, then you miss out on their charm, and then you miss out on that particular nuance of the story.
If some adolescent kid decides the violence is something beyond cool . . . and does something about it? That points to that particular child's upbringing, genetic makeup and so on. But the artist--filmmaker, author--was right to depict evil as it IS, not as people want it to be. People want their bad guys wrapped up in an evil bow. Like a sign pointing--EVIL HERE. But more often than not, bad men are alluring.
That's how they entice you. That's how little girls believe their daddies are all heroes even when they're out at night shooting other bookies for invading their turf. That's how they get new recruits. That's how they operate.
Thoughts?
And I need the identities of your undercovers.
Blow me. Not literally, though, unfortunately there's no promotion involved.
I laughed out loud. And that, is the allure of evil.
I had more than one reader tell me that they were bothered by how much they liked Uncle Two in The Roofer. Or even Frank. They're murderers. No questions asked, no guilty consciences. But they're loyal guys with totally sick, dark senses of humor--senses of humor that I share.
But does that mean I am glorifying violence? It's a question asked every time Scorsese makes a film. It was a question asked about The Godfather trilogy. It's asked about The Sopranos. And as I work on The Devil's Agents, it's something people COULD ask. But I don't. I never wonder whether I am glorifying violence. Because I'm not. I'm merely depicting it in full, round detail.
Evil is alluring. It's that simple. If it wasn't, people wouldn't sin, if you want to get all Biblical about it. Having an affair--easier than working on a marriage. Taking drugs--easier than facing your problems. Killing your estranged wife--easier than getting a divorce. At first. That's how evil sucks you in. Then it gets hard and twisted and difficult. But first . . . it has to be alluring.
Bad guys can be funny. They can be daddies. Not fathers, but dear, sweet, wonderful daddies who pick their little girls up and twirl them in an "airplane." They make sacrfices for their families sometimes--families they adore. They kiss their wives. They make love. They sit down and say grace around the dinner table. And they also kill without much thought. THAT is the reality of some gangsters. And if you play it that they don't have the humor and the allure, then you miss out on their charm, and then you miss out on that particular nuance of the story.
If some adolescent kid decides the violence is something beyond cool . . . and does something about it? That points to that particular child's upbringing, genetic makeup and so on. But the artist--filmmaker, author--was right to depict evil as it IS, not as people want it to be. People want their bad guys wrapped up in an evil bow. Like a sign pointing--EVIL HERE. But more often than not, bad men are alluring.
That's how they entice you. That's how little girls believe their daddies are all heroes even when they're out at night shooting other bookies for invading their turf. That's how they get new recruits. That's how they operate.
Thoughts?
Labels: dark humor, villains, violence


10 Comments:
I agree with you, but there's something about the way you say it that bothers me.
I guess it's because you say "I laughed out loud. And that, is the allure of evil."
But it's not. It's the allure of the evil person. People are complex, both good and bad, and evil is never pure. Laughing at the dark humor may have charmed you, but it didn't make you want to say, "Hey, come on, I'll join you, let's go blow his head off!" Right?
Also, those things that you describe that make an evil person alluring also make a GOOD person alluring.
Evil's not a noun, really. It's an adjective, an element, just like humor or affection.
Evil can be a person, but then there is the rest of what I said:
Having an affair--easier than working on a marriage. Taking drugs--easier than facing your problems. Killing your estranged wife--easier than getting a divorce. At first. That's how evil sucks you in. Then it gets hard and twisted and difficult. But first . . . it has to be alluring.
I think evil CAN be a noun. And I think, in the case of The Departed or the mob, you are not necessarily taken in by a person. You CAN be. But a lot of times you are taken in by what evil can buy you--the swagger, the attitude that you're untouchable, toughness, cache on the streets, material things . . . the ego of knowing you "own" a certain bar or neighborhood. I think you make a valid point . . . I just think it depends on how you look at it or what you're background is. When you laugh along with the bad guys, yes, you appreciate dark humor, but in real life, if you are around them and laughing with them, and you start to feel "in" with them, what that means in terms of how the rest of the world treats you . . . can turn someone's head. No, when I laugh at dark humor, I don't immediately think let me go blow someone's head off . . . but I definitely have a much grayer way of looking at the world than most people precisely because being around those types of people you can lose the touchstones of morality. You can lose a moral compass if everyone you know has a record, steals, doesn't play by any set of normal rules. And that isn't the allure of any one person, it's a moral gray that is a slippery slope to evil.
E
Natalie:
P.S. And yes, you are 100% right, the allure of evil can look a LOT like the allure of good sometimes--charisma is charisma, for instance. I don't know if you believe, spiritually or religiously, in an actual devil or actual evil vs. good. I think I tend to sometimes . . . and I think that's how evil operates.
I think Evil with a capital E can be pure. It is often enticing, and I think you stated it quite eloquently, Erica.
Thanks, Jude.
E
You know part of the alure of the Sopranos (for me) is the characterization, esp of Tony! I KNOW he's a bad person but he also has a moral code (however ambiguous) that he lives by and he's so flawed and so....dare I say HUMAN that I can definitely see where evil can be intriguing. I think similar can be said for Hannibal in Silence of the Lambs. You KNOW he's an evil person, he feels evil but he's also charismatci (which I guess goes back to your post earlier this week on villians). *g*
evil is a fact of life
all of us, has had some kind of evil to touch our lives
amie:
I agree--that show revolves, definitely, around the brilliant acting of James Gandolfini. YOu feel some vulnerability there, and then, soon as you think he's redeemable, he does something horrific, but somehow reasons it's OK.
E
tami:
Agreed. Some people see it more up close and personal than others, but it's there . . . .
E
tibia money tibia gold tibia item runescape money runescape gold runescape power leveling tibia gold runescape money runescape gold runescape accounts runescape gp runescape power leveling dofus kamas buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape items tibia item runescape accounts runescape gp wow power leveling wow powerleveling Warcraft PowerLeveling tibia money tibia gold runescape powerleveling buy dofus kamas Warcraft Power Leveling World of Warcraft PowerLeveling World of Warcraft Power Leveling Hellgate money Hellgate gold Guild Wars Gold buy Guild Wars Gold lotro gold buy lotro gold Hellgate Palladium Hellgate London Palladium Hellgate London gold runescape money runescape gold eve isk eve online isk Fiesta Silver Fiesta Gold SilkRoad Gold buy SilkRoad Gold Scions of Fate Gold SOF Gold Age Of Conan Gold AOC Gold lotro gold buy lotro gold buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape items ArchLord gold buy ArchLord gold DDO Plat tibia money tibia gold tibia item Dungeons and Dragons Online Plat
Post a Comment
<< Home