Wrong
Sometimes, when Demon Baby sleeps, I peer through the bars of his crib and hope one day I am not peering through the bars at him here. But, given his high degree of intelligence, I am thinking even IF he one day rips off the Federal Reserve, he'll be the criminal mastermind that gets away and lives in the Caymans. And in the meantime, I like watching him sleep.
And there's another thing. You see, when it's time for him to go to sleep, I take him upstairs and I read him a book. Usually, there is a tremendous amount of negotation on precisely HOW MANY books he gets. I aim for 2. He aims for 22. We meet in the middle.
Then, I put him in his crib. I have him fold his hands and I give him a prayer to recite. Something along the lines of "Angels watch over me. Help me to sleep well and grow. Amen." On bad days, something more like, "Angels, help me to be a good little boy, not a follower but a leader, but less gray hair for Mom in the meantime." Something simple. Easy. A conversation, not rote.
Then I lie down on the bed next to him, and we hold hands through the bars. (Like I said, sometimes I wonder if one day it'll be Plexiglass, but for now . . . .) And then usually in about five minutes, he falls alseep. Completely peacefully.
Now, every parenting book in the entire universe will tell you this is THE most screwed-up way to get your kids to go to sleep. But in my GUT, something tells me he will be a tiny little Demon Spawn for so short a time, it'll be over in the blink of an eye, and there is no way I would rather him fall alseep than to feel someone he loves holding his hand until slumber takes over. When morning comes, he storms into my bedroom like a Demon Baby out of Hell, and climbs into my bed for a cuddle, though lately, I am usually off walking, in which case, he picks a sibling and climbs in with them for a snuggle.
Wrong. Wrong. Wrong. They have whole BOOKS devoted to how wrong this is. FERBERIZE 'em! And you know what? F*ck the books.
Which applies to writing.
You see, for everything you want to try (writing your first book in first-person, starting with dialogue, whatever) . . . someone, some book, some writing teacher, hell, some BLOGGER will tell you it's wrong. I may even screw up once in a while and say something is the wrong way--but I don't think often. Usually, my response is "it's all in the execution." Because it is.
As a mother, I trust my gut. Nearly 100% of the time. I've never read a book on mothering. I don't buy self-help because nearly every self-help author I ever edited was pretty much on the upper end of the human toxicity scale. They can just talk a good game. I go with my gut, not someone else's. When Demon Baby wants his toenails painted, I paint them. I paint them black so it's more "manly" to appease certain family members, but I don't think I'm scarring the kid for life because he wears Pirate Toenail Polish (which is what Demon Baby and I call it).
As a writer, I trust my gut, too. I "know" innately when something's not working. I can edit people's work. I can "teach" writing. But I can't teach gut instinct.
The only way to learn to trust it is to write. A LOT.
When I was 16, I thought every short story I wrote was worthy of publication. Most of it was self-involved torturous drivel. As I continued writing, I learned I had raw talent, but that every story I wanted to tell wasn't necessarily worth telling. In other words, though I never saw a therapist, writing was acting as my therapy. Who wants to read that? For God's sake, I sure don't. I learned to cut through the crap and find a STORY to tell. With every passing year, my instinct grew. I learned craft, I became an editor, I began ghostwriting and writing for magazines. I edited more and more . . . and . . . the craft only helped hone the instinct.
So, like falling alseep with Demon Baby, I think sometimes you just gotta go with your gut. There isn't "wrong." Sometimes . . . there's just that still small voice. The more you trust it? The louder and more confident it becomes.
Thoughts?
And there's another thing. You see, when it's time for him to go to sleep, I take him upstairs and I read him a book. Usually, there is a tremendous amount of negotation on precisely HOW MANY books he gets. I aim for 2. He aims for 22. We meet in the middle.
Then, I put him in his crib. I have him fold his hands and I give him a prayer to recite. Something along the lines of "Angels watch over me. Help me to sleep well and grow. Amen." On bad days, something more like, "Angels, help me to be a good little boy, not a follower but a leader, but less gray hair for Mom in the meantime." Something simple. Easy. A conversation, not rote.
Then I lie down on the bed next to him, and we hold hands through the bars. (Like I said, sometimes I wonder if one day it'll be Plexiglass, but for now . . . .) And then usually in about five minutes, he falls alseep. Completely peacefully.
Now, every parenting book in the entire universe will tell you this is THE most screwed-up way to get your kids to go to sleep. But in my GUT, something tells me he will be a tiny little Demon Spawn for so short a time, it'll be over in the blink of an eye, and there is no way I would rather him fall alseep than to feel someone he loves holding his hand until slumber takes over. When morning comes, he storms into my bedroom like a Demon Baby out of Hell, and climbs into my bed for a cuddle, though lately, I am usually off walking, in which case, he picks a sibling and climbs in with them for a snuggle.
Wrong. Wrong. Wrong. They have whole BOOKS devoted to how wrong this is. FERBERIZE 'em! And you know what? F*ck the books.
Which applies to writing.
You see, for everything you want to try (writing your first book in first-person, starting with dialogue, whatever) . . . someone, some book, some writing teacher, hell, some BLOGGER will tell you it's wrong. I may even screw up once in a while and say something is the wrong way--but I don't think often. Usually, my response is "it's all in the execution." Because it is.
As a mother, I trust my gut. Nearly 100% of the time. I've never read a book on mothering. I don't buy self-help because nearly every self-help author I ever edited was pretty much on the upper end of the human toxicity scale. They can just talk a good game. I go with my gut, not someone else's. When Demon Baby wants his toenails painted, I paint them. I paint them black so it's more "manly" to appease certain family members, but I don't think I'm scarring the kid for life because he wears Pirate Toenail Polish (which is what Demon Baby and I call it).
As a writer, I trust my gut, too. I "know" innately when something's not working. I can edit people's work. I can "teach" writing. But I can't teach gut instinct.
The only way to learn to trust it is to write. A LOT.
When I was 16, I thought every short story I wrote was worthy of publication. Most of it was self-involved torturous drivel. As I continued writing, I learned I had raw talent, but that every story I wanted to tell wasn't necessarily worth telling. In other words, though I never saw a therapist, writing was acting as my therapy. Who wants to read that? For God's sake, I sure don't. I learned to cut through the crap and find a STORY to tell. With every passing year, my instinct grew. I learned craft, I became an editor, I began ghostwriting and writing for magazines. I edited more and more . . . and . . . the craft only helped hone the instinct.
So, like falling alseep with Demon Baby, I think sometimes you just gotta go with your gut. There isn't "wrong." Sometimes . . . there's just that still small voice. The more you trust it? The louder and more confident it becomes.
Thoughts?
Labels: voice


32 Comments:
You know, I love the analogy between motherhood advice and writing advice... While I like talking about writing and various aspects of craft, I have to agree that every rule can be broken by the right author... I think what newer writers don't know is that you have to master the rules, or at least be aware of them before you choose to break them - but that's a rant for another day.
I love all the people with the parenting advice and most of it sounds great - IN THEORY. I especially love the ones you drop all these platitudes about raising children without actually having any, or the wonderous how to writers doling out parenting advice while their own offspring are raised by nannies. I have read a few psychology books that zone in on early years with a focus on parenting, though that's more for interested knowledge than any kind of a 'how to'...
I will fully admit that I'm riding by the seat of my pants in most things and, whatever the 'proper' method is today will likely look archaic tomorrow. But I do snuggle whenever they let me, like you, I have it firmly in mind that the phase only lasts a while, never to come again.
Nice article, Erica.
I'm sure I mis-speak that sort of thing all the time. Everything is about what works for you. In the kinky world, LOL, you wouldn't believe the discussions that go on about what's called what and who's what label and the right way to do this or that. Drives me insane! Whatever floats your boat, you know?
But the baby thing? Oh, gosh, Erica. I can't say I know anything about parenting. It's a totally different thing than teaching, I know. I do get to watch a bunch of parents do it, and I do notice certain trends I file away for when I have kids. The kind that cuddle and hold their kids alot, alot, alot? They are the smilingest, happiest babies you'd ever see. Even when they're older. Not that it's that way for every baby, LOL.
Besides, imagining Demon Baby, it won't be long before he's persuading you out so he can grab his flashlight and read those 22 books himself under the covers, LOL.
I agree. The best writers, too, tend to be voracious readers as well as practiced writers. Reading a wide variety of books, stories, poems, essays, etc. can teach what legions of books, classes, and conference sessions on creative writing can never begin to teach.
As for trusting your instinct, it's the risky writing that often starts whole new genres.
Namaste, E. You are RIGHT on. :)
Hi Merry:
I think that's really sound advice--at least knowing the wirting "rules" before you go an break them. I've pointed out things to writers before who have looked at me with a puzzled, "I have no idea what you are even saying" look. Like POV "hopping" from head to head. Not that it
can't work or that some writers will do so, but a newer writer not even being aware that's what they are doing.
spy:
The kinky world, huh? One of these days we're sitting down for a L-O-N-G cup of coffee together. :-)
And yes . . . I am totally sure I mis-speak sometimes, which is one reason I wrote this.
E
booklady:
My father always gave me that advice. You can't be a writer until you've read everything you can get your hands on.
E
Hey Heather:
Thanks! :-)
E
Did someone say kinky? =)
wrong wrong wrong!
Never have been one for rules. Luckily, when I had my kids I was young enough to still know everything and adamant about raising them MY way. I have terrific kids. Miraculously so. Really. =) (and ds sported painted toenails for a while and was fond enough of lipstick his dad wanted me to confess he wasn't really his)
Neurotic sister with a gazillion years of child studies education under her belt before she had kids and a library of parenting books has children who are chronically ill because they don't eat or sleep and she can't take them out in public. Ever! Just sayin'
Not nearly as good at applying this to my writing. I'm forever trying to figure out if my gut instinct is pulling me in the right direction or if my gut is just complaining about that left over chili I fed it for breakfast.
lainey:
You just gotta go with emotion on the page and turn off that internal editor, then edit it into something story-like. My gut is what I think some people call the zone, at least when it comes to writing.
xo
E
hahaha Spy, yes! I think this happens very often with minority groups (and I'm not talking about racial issues.) For some reason people who have a minority viewpoint feel the need to form groups about it. And they need to have rules about it. Because if there are no rules, then what they feel, think, or do isn't real because it doesn't have enough popular support to be made real.
So much of reality I think really IS perception. And so I think people in groups like this tend to get a little rabid about their labels because it's so much harder to feel "real" than it is for people who's chosen lifestyle or belief or viewpoint is in complete keeping with the culture they live in.
The only solution for this I think is a strong dose of self possession. Knowing who you are and being able to let go of "everybody else agreeing with it."
Love, love, love your Demon Baby stories, Erica.
I do read books on writing (though not so much), but I too go with my gut. I'm glad I know the basics, but my objective is to write characters that people care about and a story that touches readers' hearts. The only way I can do that is to write from my own heart.
I removed two characters from a story because a couple of early readers, half a dozen or so agents, and nine big time editors ALL told me to remove them.
I was sure I was right and they were ALL wrong. But I took them out. It's no longer my story.
I want to sit down with you and Spy when you have that cup of coffee and long talk.
I think if all writers followed all the so called rules all the time, we'd have a lot of boring books. I love to find an author who does something different and it works! It's like finding a hidden treasure.
As for that whole teach babies to get themselves to sleep. Please. Humans are pack animals. Babies want to be close to mommy or daddy or whoever for a reason. I think you just have to do what works. My chiropractors (husband and wife) have always done the family bed thing. It works for them. Personally, I couldn't sleep when I put my daughter in bed with me. Not that it didn't happen. I just didn't get much sleep.
Well, you're the parent of a mostly-adult child, so you can probably take a step back and say: What difference did it make?
We always tried to be matter-of-fact about getting the boys to bed when they were little, with varying degrees of success. Both kids were, generally, pretty good sleepers, the older one better than the younger.
I think we were lucky and I'm not convinced anything we did made much of a difference. Sometimes, when they were babies, we had them in bed with us, or with us on a chair, or lying next to them in their cribs or child beds. Whatever worked.
In terms of long-term affect on the kids, I wish the writers of child-rearing books would get a life.
In terms of its affect on your sleep, well... whatever works.
Okay, Erica, your story with Demon Baby today brushed my heart...as they all do. I'm a gut-gal, and very comfortable with it. Basically,it talks and I listen.
And those craft books and I don't get along either. I'd rather spend the time doing what works for me, than squeezing into someone else's bus. LOL.
Hi Zoe:
That's an interesting perspective . . . I don't know. My Significant Other is Mexican, and my children all have Hispanic surnames--and in one case an Hispanic first name. I think we band closer together, especially in the anti-immigration climate right now. I get about as incensed as a person can over prejudice toward my children when people find out they are Mexican-American. You see people's faces drop a little and you get this, "OOOH, I had NO idea you were Mexican." As if now they have grown three heads. But . . . I don't know if we feel a need to label our reality in a certain minority way. I don't know . . . I will have to think about that. Thanks for your point of view/sharing.
E
edie:
I don't read books on writing mostly because my free time is so limited that I read things I adore--like physics or astronomy.
But I think if I did, I would be open to suggestions but very aware it's just "one" way to do it, not necessarily the "right" one (since I don't think there is a right one).
E
stephen . . .
That's a really tough spot. Especially since opinions were consistent. My point of view on things like that is there are some things that I personally love that will never sell. And that's OK. They're MINE. And there are some things that I love that WILL sell because it's the right intersection of market and passion on my part.
E
Liz and Mark:
I'm with you both on that . . . I just think parenting--and writing--are very much "what works" kind of areas.
As for my oldest . . . she was NOTHING like Demon. All my kids are gifted, and she had this amazing IQ and would literally sit and read--even as a baby, she would look at picture books for hours, or do puzzles--by herself, very independent. She knew ALl the states, on an unlabeled map, all their capitals, and all their state flowers and products (Georgia peaches and so on) and 2 1/2. And she would simply . . . go to bed. It was bed time, I said good-night, rocked her, tucked her in, shut off the light, and off she went. Child #2 . . . same thing. Number 3 came along--she was a Family Bed kid until age 8. Now Demon, who is a crib baby but likes to hold hands. I think I decided, in a very almost Buddhist sense of your children each have their own journey, that I would sort of see what each of them needed and then adapt. And that's what I've done, though Demon stumps me in ways none of the others did.
E
ladonna:
I love the way you put it. I'll ride my own bus, too.
E
Parenting is like writing... Good analogy. I look at my ten yr old and I can see every mistake I made and the lessons I learned along the way. Looking at those mistakes I hope means I don't make them again and am a better mother to him and his 5 yr old brother. Hind sight is 20/20 but if someone would have told me do this, don't do that I wouldn't have listened. I painted my son's toenails pink because he wanted to do what I was doing and I bonded with him over that like I would have if he had been a girl. Having 2 boys there aren't too many moments like that and they are fewer and farther between as they grow. I held my babies all day when they were sick and only put them down to pee. I would tell the doctor I was doing what she said I should but really did what I thought was right.
I am a new writer and I hope I am making mistakes I can learn from and grow with just like I did with motherhood. I hope 5, 10, 15 novels from now I will be that much stronger that much better. Right now I am enjoying writing my babies too much to fully comprehend all the mistakes I am making. I guess that is why God invented editors!
Wow, Beth . . . what a beautiful and eloquent addition to the discussion.
E
Hey Erica,
I wasn't talking about racial issues, I was talking about viewpoints. I didn't want to specify any one group of people but for example...minority political groups, minority religious views, minority sexual proclivities, etc. There is a tendency when one is going against the grain of society to form little cloisters. It's normal for everyone to get into groups with those of like mind, it just seems that those in minority viewpoint groups tend to get very specific when labeling themselves because so much of their identity is dependent upon their viewpoint being valid. So there is a lot of pomp and circumstance surrounding it because mainstream society doesn't support it quite as strongly. I've observed this phenomena as both an outsider and insider, though when I've been an insider I've usually bucked whatever the popular "rules" of the group I'm in are. Not to be difficult so much as...I don't get someone who is different in the way they view the world around them wanting nevertheless so much to be "the same" as all the others in their "counterculture" movement.
I should probably use smileys more so I don't sound so serious all the time, I just always feel like a big goober when I use them.
I read parenting books like I read books on writing: it's good to know the rules so that you can figure out the best and most creative ways to break them. Where's the fun of breaking rules if you don't know that you are breaking them? :)
I do follow the rule that you just go with what works in that situation. It applies to both parenting and writing.
As far as "advice" from people about topics they have no experience in... well, I try to listen from "I have something to learn" - and sometimes that works. It is hard to get around the prejudice we (many of us anyway) carry that those with no experience cannot contribute. Listening in that way can sometimes uncover surprises. This is the same way I read the "how to" books about parenting and writing.
When I fail to actually listen to people, no matter what the topic, I try to clean it up with them and have them tell me again. Contribution to others can be receiving as well as listening. I find this works well with my daughters.
This reminds me of what Yoda told Luke in Empire Strikes Back: "You must unlearn what you have learned."
Damn is that one true. What happens to us from the days when we were kids making sh*it up, to stressed out adults making make believe much harder than it should be?
As for the Demon Baby and the Little Dude, may they never meet. My son will get your son off an all charges (and demand an apology), or vice versa. ;-)
Mary
zoe:
Very interesting!
E
Mary:
LOL!
E
The only way to learn to trust it (gut instinct) is to write. A LOT.
Amen.
And isn't it a great feeling when you just KNOW you nailed it?
Thanks Erica for this post. Great one. As I was also the mom that went against all the advice and have kids who like me to lay with them til they sleep an like to come in the morning for cuddles, I completely relate. We have such a short time with them now, let's enjoy it every second.
And yes, following my gut on all matters is routine for me.
Hi Ello:
This journey through life is over in a flash. My only motto, most of the time, is LOVE MORE. That especially applies to my babies. And by babies I mean even my 17-year-old!
E
Post a Comment
<< Home