Do I Know You?
With me, pretty much what you see (exhausted mom of four, writer, odd around the edges) is what you get. I don't like small talk. I prefer to keep to myself, but I have very, very close friends that mean everything to me. Family is my number-one priority. Then my prayer life. Then my volunteering life. Then writing. Sometimes the order of the last two shuffles, but not much.
I wear my (typically bleeding) heart on my sleeve. If I want to cry, I don't care who sees me. If I am in a silly mood, I don't care if I am out in public. I am always the first person out on the dance floor at a wedding.
Baby Girl and I went out for dinner. She had given me the most glorious Mother's Day card (hand-painted by her) with an essay inside on why her mom is so special. Suffice it to say, virtually every sentence had some form of the following: "My mom is very different from most moms, and that's part of why I love her so much." "My mom is kind of crazy a lot of the time, but if you know her, that's why you'd love her." So at dinner, I asked her, "Why did your whole essay resound with 'my mom is weird.'" To which she replied, "Have you met yourself?" I asked if she wanted a normal mom. To which she replied, "No, I'll keep you." Which was gratifying, since she is rather stuck with me.
But in the end, Baby Girl's essay aside, I feel I am unknowable. There is so much pain and joy and heartache, and thoughts and prayer way, way beneath the surface. I don't feel that anyone knows me fully. And I feel that way about most people. We spend our lives trying to connect with people, but in the end, do we REALLY know them?
Which brings me to my work-in-progress. I have a couple of characters that I "get." I see them, feel them. In my mind, I see him brush a stray piece of hair from her face. I see her pausing to watch him before he knows she's there. I feel their breaths. But there--off-stage for now--is her domineering, mean father. Him, I don't know. It's not that I can't write him. I think I can. But I don't know what motivates him. I don't KNOW him. I can't wrap my mind around him. And while I don't have Writer's Block* (see end of post), THIS is a block that is holding up my work. I don't get him.
At one point, a certain member of my writers' group and I would have rather large disagreements about one of his characters. I think he felt he knew this character . . . and I didn't. Because it's not my work--I know to a very large extent he was right. On the flipside, we're trying to make our characters knowable--not just to us, but to our readers.
I also realize that the MAIN reason I don't know this character in my work-in-progress is I have no idea what motivates him. What makes him get out bed in the morning. What jerks his proverbial chain. For me, I get out of bed for the coffee brewing, for the chance to see Demon Baby with the peace of sleep on his face. I get up for my kids because I know if I am not "motivating" them out the door, their days will be a mess and spill back onto my day. I get up because loads of laundry are waiting to get done. I get up to blog and "see" all of you. I get up to pray.
So . . . are we knowable? Is what we know the EVIDENCE of our existence? Am I knowable only by what I do? Where I choose to spend my time? Are your characters knowable? And what obligation do you have to your readers to make them knowable?
Discuss. :-)
*My Writer's Block asterisk? I read the NY papers in the morning. James Frey made Page Six of the New York Post with this comment: JAMES Frey made his triumphant return to the literary limelight Tuesday night at the Blender Theater, where he walked through his adoring fans flanked by two huge body-builders and took the stage to read from his first novel, "Bright Shiny Morning." As jazz pianist Eric Lewis played, Frey read a passage about LA's gun culture under a slide show of Terry Richardson photographs of tattooed, heavily armed gang members. Asked if he'd suffered any droughts of inspiration during his 10 months of typing, Frey replied, "Writer's block is for chumps. To me this is a job, like being a banker, or a teacher. You never hear of banker's block."
To which I wanted to hurl my computer. I think the man is a jackass.
I wear my (typically bleeding) heart on my sleeve. If I want to cry, I don't care who sees me. If I am in a silly mood, I don't care if I am out in public. I am always the first person out on the dance floor at a wedding.
Baby Girl and I went out for dinner. She had given me the most glorious Mother's Day card (hand-painted by her) with an essay inside on why her mom is so special. Suffice it to say, virtually every sentence had some form of the following: "My mom is very different from most moms, and that's part of why I love her so much." "My mom is kind of crazy a lot of the time, but if you know her, that's why you'd love her." So at dinner, I asked her, "Why did your whole essay resound with 'my mom is weird.'" To which she replied, "Have you met yourself?" I asked if she wanted a normal mom. To which she replied, "No, I'll keep you." Which was gratifying, since she is rather stuck with me.
But in the end, Baby Girl's essay aside, I feel I am unknowable. There is so much pain and joy and heartache, and thoughts and prayer way, way beneath the surface. I don't feel that anyone knows me fully. And I feel that way about most people. We spend our lives trying to connect with people, but in the end, do we REALLY know them?
Which brings me to my work-in-progress. I have a couple of characters that I "get." I see them, feel them. In my mind, I see him brush a stray piece of hair from her face. I see her pausing to watch him before he knows she's there. I feel their breaths. But there--off-stage for now--is her domineering, mean father. Him, I don't know. It's not that I can't write him. I think I can. But I don't know what motivates him. I don't KNOW him. I can't wrap my mind around him. And while I don't have Writer's Block* (see end of post), THIS is a block that is holding up my work. I don't get him.
At one point, a certain member of my writers' group and I would have rather large disagreements about one of his characters. I think he felt he knew this character . . . and I didn't. Because it's not my work--I know to a very large extent he was right. On the flipside, we're trying to make our characters knowable--not just to us, but to our readers.
I also realize that the MAIN reason I don't know this character in my work-in-progress is I have no idea what motivates him. What makes him get out bed in the morning. What jerks his proverbial chain. For me, I get out of bed for the coffee brewing, for the chance to see Demon Baby with the peace of sleep on his face. I get up for my kids because I know if I am not "motivating" them out the door, their days will be a mess and spill back onto my day. I get up because loads of laundry are waiting to get done. I get up to blog and "see" all of you. I get up to pray.
So . . . are we knowable? Is what we know the EVIDENCE of our existence? Am I knowable only by what I do? Where I choose to spend my time? Are your characters knowable? And what obligation do you have to your readers to make them knowable?
Discuss. :-)
*My Writer's Block asterisk? I read the NY papers in the morning. James Frey made Page Six of the New York Post with this comment: JAMES Frey made his triumphant return to the literary limelight Tuesday night at the Blender Theater, where he walked through his adoring fans flanked by two huge body-builders and took the stage to read from his first novel, "Bright Shiny Morning." As jazz pianist Eric Lewis played, Frey read a passage about LA's gun culture under a slide show of Terry Richardson photographs of tattooed, heavily armed gang members. Asked if he'd suffered any droughts of inspiration during his 10 months of typing, Frey replied, "Writer's block is for chumps. To me this is a job, like being a banker, or a teacher. You never hear of banker's block."
To which I wanted to hurl my computer. I think the man is a jackass.
Labels: character motivation, writer's block


27 Comments:
Erica, I wonder if coming so close to death gave you the freedom to be different. My sister and her husband are the worst dancers. Seriously. They don't move to the rhythm, they hop up and down. (Obviously made for each other.) Yet they're the first two on a dance floor, too. And I love watching them. Their joy makes me smile.
I'm kind of a private person, even in my blogs. I don't open myself up as much as you do, so you probably don't know me. I'm not sure what obligation we have to make our characters "knowable." Our obligation --mine, at least -- is to bring them to bring them to life, make them real and interesting. I don't think that's the same thing as knowable.
About James Frey, I don't get his "adoring fans." I won't read his book.
Hi Edie:
Oddly enough, I am a LOT more open in writing than in person.
As for the freedom to be different, I don't know. I think I had "different" parents, which I didn't fully appreciate until I was an adult. That, and I think getting divorced spun me down a different path. I was pretty emotionally beaten up at that point, and I think I really grabbed at the second chance.
As for Frey--don't get the fans either.
E
Don't get me going on Frey, please. If I understand this correctly, the path to bestselling fiction writing is:
1. Fake a dramatic memoir.
2. Be humiliated on Oprah.
3. Come back and write a novel.
4. Therefore, the press and media in general, who should know better (but clearly don't) can write about what a "comeback" he's having while a hundred thousand or so hardworking, talented novelists toil away in obscurity.
Give. Me. A. Break.
I was thinking of this before your post, so I'll go and ask it here, because I almost e-mailed you to ask you anyway (which sort of explains my mood today, I guess).
Who do Buddhists pray to?
Mark:
Give me a break indeed. His self-absorption (as evidenced by his comment) continues.
As for prayer . . . I'm a mix of many things, and am a theist. But as the Dalai Lama says, first and foremost, "My religion is kindness."
E
"How can you know me and still love me?
"That's what it's all about, Preppy."
--from the movie Love Story
Confession: I also liked The Lake House.
I'm a sucker for gooey, sentimental tripe--if it's done well.
Now you know one more thing about me. ;)
Jude:
Hated Love Story.
Liked Lake House, as long as I didn't try to reason with their time travel.
E
Erica:
Did you know Eric Segal and Al Gore were roomies in college (Harvard?), and that the Oliver character in Love Story was based loosely on Gore? I didn't know that until 2000 when Gore was running for President, but I thought it was kind of interesting.
The screenplay was fairly true to the novel (really a novella, at around 160 pages). Why did you hate it? Just curious.
Jude:
I just didn't find her this carefree wonderful person (her acting is pretty awful) . . . and everything was written/acted pretty boradly with very little subtlety to it. So for me it didn't work--but I think largely because for me to really weep over this movie, I needed to LIKE her and I didn't.
E
Erica:
Interesting. I thought the acting was superb and the writing brilliant. Just goes to show how subjective everything is in this business...
Does anyone really know each other? My girlfriend and I were discussing this last night. I wrote a long piece that encompassed the complex relationship between me and my Dad. She read it and we cried together. Then we talked about parents and how we kids don't think they have a life before us.
So our first model of how to be with other people is with people who only came into existence when we did. At least until we get old enough to understand that they had a life before us and experiences that shaped them. And that their life with us didn’t only involve us.
There are things that I have not shared with another human being, and things I’ve only shared with my therapist, and even more things I’ve shared with a select group of friends – very select and very small in number. And then there are the things that I am willing to share with anyone depending on the circumstances. I’m self-edited and the more I learn about life and about boundaries, the more I edit.
Writer’s Block? I learned there really is no such thing as writer’s block when I did the NaNoWriMo. Nothing stops me from putting words on paper. Putting the right words on paper is another story and that’s where I get stumped sometimes. If I give myself permission to just write anything, even junk, then the words come. And they’re usually not that bad after all.
I’m feeling in a positive mood today, so no comment on Frey.
Seriously, he is. Sheesh. Creating something out of thin air is really hard. Just coming up with words. It's excruciating, sometimes.
(Can you tell the only writing I've been doing this week and last is non-fiction? Oh, god, shoot me now, PLEASE. I keep working all day, and I swear I get 5 words done an hour. It's awful.)
Even our own self is a little bit of a mystery to ourselves. Fiction helps us understand ourselves and other people a little better. At least, that's probably as close to why I write as anything else.
You're right, though. So much of DH is still a mystery. He thinks he's got me all figured out, but he has NO CLUE, LOL.
You know I am actually a very private person, compared to my sister who likes to tell everybody all the details of her life. I hate that. I want to keep aspects of my life private because that's what they are, private. Some people are easy to know. They are what you see. Some are the proverbial deep waters. I would rather be the deep water. It doesn't mean I'm not what I seem. Within minutes of meeting me, you should know my basic personality, but to actually get to know me, you would need to spend alot more time with me. And I think being able to find out something new about a person is part of the pleasure you have in their friendship.
And Frey is an ass. No question.
Speaking of how subjective everything is...
***AMERICAN IDOL SPOILER ALERT***
***********************************
My guy is in the finale next week, while your guy is home smoking a doob. Ha! Ha!
;)
Hi Sarah:
I agree . . . and in real life, I expect that people are unknowable. And yet, I have to know my characters before I can get them on the page. It's a delicate dance, for me, with this one character.
E
Spy:
Men . . . .
;-)
E
Hi Ello:
I always say I am the kind of person people eithe rlove or hate on sight. I don't seem to evoke middle of the road anything . . .
And I also know people who spill their entire lives within a short time of meeting them. I don't know. I think I am so weary of my whole life history sometimes that the THOUGHT of recounting it makes me ill.
Live in the moment.
And yeah. He's an ass.
E
Jude;
AI SPOILER FOR YOU NEW ZEALAND FOLKS!!!!!!!
**********************************
Frankly, I think my guy is happy to be home smoking a joint. I am now rooting for Cook. Oldest is in love with him.
E
tsk, tsk, Jude. I thought I knew you so well and here you are getting all syrupy sentimental with movie choices AND copping to an American Idol addiction. Maybe it's you that sparked a l'il somethin' ;-)
K, I'll be good now.
I'm with you, Sarah & Spy on this one. I don't think you ever really really know anyone. Including yourself.
lainey:
I think that's our journey.
E
I so love your blogs, Erica! And I agree, it's the journey; re-discovering who we really are. I think it's a beautiful gift to let our children see.
And how did Frey bounce back like that? I dislike what he did very much, and saw his Oprah appearance when he got caught. I don't understand how he could have fan base.
I think Mr. Frey has a lot to learn. His words will eventually bite him in the you know what.
Does anyone really know who we are? Or how we got to where we are? I often wonder how I survived my younger years. Some things should never be spoken of. Its probably better they don't know us so well after all.
ladonna:
I sometimes posit that if he were truly homely, didn't have a cocky air to him, etc., there'd be no one giving him another deal.
E
aimless:
That's the fear when you have kids. You have NO idea how you made it, but KNOW it was by grace/fate/luck . . . and now you worry for your own kids.
E
***AMERICAN IDOL SPOILER ALERT***
Erica:
I think David Cook is really good as well, but would somebody please buy the guy a hair brush?!?!
Lainey:
I know, LOL! I need to start making more manly comments. What can I say? When people ask me what kind of movies I like, I say, "good ones." I will say I'm more often drawn to crime dramas like No country For Old Men than to romances. Erica and I sometimes disagree, but when we do I'm always right.
There. Now you know me. Just remember, jackasses need lovin' too. ;)
Erica, to me SPOILER means read on. Damn! This season's American Idol has been the best yet. I can't miss it.
Jude, I saw No Country for Old Men on the plane coming back from Italy and the plane noise meant I missed all the pertinent conversations, so I didn't understand much at all. Can you tell me what it was all about? Not the actual story but why it was considered so great by the public and critics.
Suzanne:
This review pretty much sums it up for me.
Thanks Jude. That was very insightful and I am sorry I missed so much of Tommy Lee's dialogue. I have always loved him as an actor.
Post a Comment
<< Home