My First Time
Baby Girl had her poetry reading last night (she won a contest). She marched up in front of a ROOM full (big room full) of adults, some students, teachers, etc., all but a handful of whom were strangers, to read her poetry. And she was shorter than the lectern. Literally. She stood behind it and there was no part of her--not even the tip-top of her head--visible. She stood on tiptoes, they lowered the microphone. I could see the top of her hair and her forehead. It actually highlighted how tiny and young she is. And she read her poem with confidence she didn't feel (she said she was nervous) and drew huge applause.
When she made it back to me, of course I told her how well she did--she really was wonderful. How proud I was and am. And then . . . I said, "You should be a poet when you grow up. No one really aspires to that anymore." "What kind of job could I have?" "You could be a college professor and write poetry." We talked about that for a while. Then I said, as I often do, "You should follow your heart and not worry about money. Do what makes you happy." And we moved on.
But I started thinking about her big night in light of this post that Stephen Parrish directed me to. That first time you realize your gift with words is a gift.
I wrote a lot of short stories as a child. They were usually about mice for whatever reason. Mice with complex family relationships who lived in libraries. Mice that were not python food (I really, REALLY hate Oldest Son's snake). And much as I loved writing them and reading them aloud to my poor unsuspecting grandparents and parents . . . I didn't think it was a gift.
Until 7th grade. Now to be utterly clear, I had a 7th-grade English teacher who was . . . I am sorry to say it . . . like a caricature of the unmarried spinster. I don't want to publicly skewer this woman, though I presume she is long deceased. But wrap your minds around a really, really plain woman with long frizzy hair piled high on her head. And she would assign us essays. The most amazing thing was . . . sometimes she said, "They don't have to be true." Like the ol' "What I Did on Summer Vacation" one they trot out every year? She said, "It doesn't have to be true." So I made up a story about how I spent it in a government experiment about underwater colonization. She read mine aloud.
I can still remember the angry reactions I got from classmates. "That couldn't have happened!" "Well, she said it didn't have to be true!" And then some in the class thought it was amazing and fun and how did I think of it. I had a lot of details about how our colony worked, where it was located--I even had a moment of crisis written in there about when it appeared that our glassed-in colony had a leak.
From there, we as a class went on to other stories and essays. And it kind of got to be routine that she read mine aloud. And finally, at some point toward the end of the year, my teacher pulled me aside and said, "Have you ever thought about being a writer?" And for whatever reason, I hadn't. I had wanted to be a doctor or a vet. But I hadn't thought about spinning my stories for a wider audience. I thought about it . . . making up stuff for a living. I tucked it away in my head.
Years went by. This movie came out. That seemed like an important job. It combined writing skills with saving the world! (Important music crescendo please.) But after I went to college, I discovered a case of terminal shyness and more importantly, the sense that I didn't really want to PRY (unfailingly polite) was going to doom that career. I just didn't want to butt into other people's business. So my best friend from college went on to journalism, and I became a book editor. Just the perfect job for a woman who preferred to be left in a cubicle with manuscripts for company.
But in my head . . . I never forgot that 7th-grade teacher. And I kept writing stuff that wasn't true. Fast forward . . . here I am.
Yes. Here I am . . . On a poetry night with Baby Girl. And I can SEE she has something. I can see it when she wakes up first thing in the morning, goes to her poetry notebook, scratches out one word ("It's not quite right, Mom . . . it throws off the rhythm.") for another BETTER word. I see it.
I think last night was an important night. I hope she remembers it always. What it felt to stand at a microphone behind a lectern taller than she was, in her brand-new outfit for the occasion, with her big sister's borrowed necklace, and read HER poem.
What was your first time?
When she made it back to me, of course I told her how well she did--she really was wonderful. How proud I was and am. And then . . . I said, "You should be a poet when you grow up. No one really aspires to that anymore." "What kind of job could I have?" "You could be a college professor and write poetry." We talked about that for a while. Then I said, as I often do, "You should follow your heart and not worry about money. Do what makes you happy." And we moved on.
But I started thinking about her big night in light of this post that Stephen Parrish directed me to. That first time you realize your gift with words is a gift.
I wrote a lot of short stories as a child. They were usually about mice for whatever reason. Mice with complex family relationships who lived in libraries. Mice that were not python food (I really, REALLY hate Oldest Son's snake). And much as I loved writing them and reading them aloud to my poor unsuspecting grandparents and parents . . . I didn't think it was a gift.
Until 7th grade. Now to be utterly clear, I had a 7th-grade English teacher who was . . . I am sorry to say it . . . like a caricature of the unmarried spinster. I don't want to publicly skewer this woman, though I presume she is long deceased. But wrap your minds around a really, really plain woman with long frizzy hair piled high on her head. And she would assign us essays. The most amazing thing was . . . sometimes she said, "They don't have to be true." Like the ol' "What I Did on Summer Vacation" one they trot out every year? She said, "It doesn't have to be true." So I made up a story about how I spent it in a government experiment about underwater colonization. She read mine aloud.
I can still remember the angry reactions I got from classmates. "That couldn't have happened!" "Well, she said it didn't have to be true!" And then some in the class thought it was amazing and fun and how did I think of it. I had a lot of details about how our colony worked, where it was located--I even had a moment of crisis written in there about when it appeared that our glassed-in colony had a leak.
From there, we as a class went on to other stories and essays. And it kind of got to be routine that she read mine aloud. And finally, at some point toward the end of the year, my teacher pulled me aside and said, "Have you ever thought about being a writer?" And for whatever reason, I hadn't. I had wanted to be a doctor or a vet. But I hadn't thought about spinning my stories for a wider audience. I thought about it . . . making up stuff for a living. I tucked it away in my head.
Years went by. This movie came out. That seemed like an important job. It combined writing skills with saving the world! (Important music crescendo please.) But after I went to college, I discovered a case of terminal shyness and more importantly, the sense that I didn't really want to PRY (unfailingly polite) was going to doom that career. I just didn't want to butt into other people's business. So my best friend from college went on to journalism, and I became a book editor. Just the perfect job for a woman who preferred to be left in a cubicle with manuscripts for company.
But in my head . . . I never forgot that 7th-grade teacher. And I kept writing stuff that wasn't true. Fast forward . . . here I am.
Yes. Here I am . . . On a poetry night with Baby Girl. And I can SEE she has something. I can see it when she wakes up first thing in the morning, goes to her poetry notebook, scratches out one word ("It's not quite right, Mom . . . it throws off the rhythm.") for another BETTER word. I see it.
I think last night was an important night. I hope she remembers it always. What it felt to stand at a microphone behind a lectern taller than she was, in her brand-new outfit for the occasion, with her big sister's borrowed necklace, and read HER poem.
What was your first time?


24 Comments:
The first time I remember getting encouragement for writing was in second grade when my teacher read my song in front of the class. I can't remember how it went exactly, but we were studying pre-Columbus native American cultures and I was struck by how it seemed the women worked much harder than the men. Maybe my (female) teacher appreciated my theme more than the actual writing. :)
Jude:
That is the theme of my life.
E
The book lover thing had always been there, but the real epiphany was in college when I read an essay by Stephen King. I tried my hand at a short story and was hooked.
My oldest son doesn't want to be a writer. He is a writer. He writes every day (sometimes I think he writes more than I do, since he's not saddled with interviews, transcribing interviews, bookkeeping, or research).
We chatted about careers the other day and he's interested in several things, music and history, but I commented that although I'm sure he'd be great at whatever he focused on, I noted that although his favorite subject is band and he plays 2 instruments well and is learning a 3rd, he doesn't go out of his way to actually play and practice. But writing he does on his own often for hours at a time. And I further commented that that was something to think about when choosing what you wanted to do for a living.
Gah! I'v been writing since I was four, so I can't remember having that first moment. But after my parents got divorced, I remember writing a poem in the 6th grade and surprising myself by how good it was. My suspicions were confirmed when others read it, saying the same, and then I wondered how I was able to write the poem.
I learned to doubt young. lol.
Mark:
Baby Girl is a poet for sure. She is also HUGELY interested in fashion (fan of quirky clothes, like Betsy Johnson) and art. I could see her actually one day being a fashion writer or something . . . she even writes poetry about clothes she imagines herself designing (like catalog copy). We'll see what happens. :-)
E
Heather:
Wow . .. that inner critic showed up early. :-)
E
Yay, Baby Girl! I'm sure she'll remember it.
My first time was also in primary school. Grade 3 or 4 I think, a short story that won right up until the end stage where we had to actually get on a stage and read aloud. My voice abandoned me. Completely!
Groovy Girl is an incredibly talented cartoonist. From the time she could hold a crayon she would sit for hours on end creating her fairies and such. We always figured art school was a no-brainer but she took a left on us just in the last few months. She's concluded that she doesn't want to be a cartoonist for a living BECAUSE its what she loves to do. She fears if she did it all day for others it might not hold the same level of joy and escape for her as it does now.
It was in high school. A teacher took me aside and asked if I had any ambition to write. Wasn't even an English teacher. Funny how a simple gesture that takes just a minute out of your day can dramatically alter someone's life.
It's not relevant, but I want to say it anyway: the teacher was later fired when it was revealed she was a lesbian.
great post and congratulations to your daughter! I was fortunate to have an English teacher in high school that loved me and loved everything I wrote and praised me for always thinking outside the box. Even then I wrote humorously. My essay on the greatest invention of all time was on ice cream. I went to college and had a writing instructor that was mean and nasty and hated everyone's stuff and I was not doing well until I realized she had a biting sense of humor and I wrote a piece that was very dark, dark sarcastic humor which she loved and promptly gave me an A on. I forgot about writing creatively once I determined to go to law school and be a lawyer. But I guess it kept calling to me and finally I changed my life so I could write again. Don't know if I did the right thing but hopefully I did.
Hi Lainey:
My oldest sometimes feels that about music.
E
stephen:
As if gender or sexuality have anything to do with inspiring students.
E
Ello:
YOU? Dark and sarcastic??? LOL!
:-)
E
P.S. You could write a book on bathroom humor alone!
My 4th grade teacher (who has since died of cancer and I think she was a closeted lesbian) got me started reading. Very long story of us being in and out of each other's lives for over 5 years. She was a huge influence in my life.
I wrote poetry in elementary school. Mostly about drugs and how they kill people - just a touch of alcoholism in my family, like everywhere.
I think I started writing short stories then, too. I put together a book of these writings (my best friend wrote some of them) and gave it to the 6th grade teacher we both thought didn't like us. It was a bribe. I think it worked.
Submitted a short story to a magazine when I was 16 and was crushed by the detailed rejection letter. Well, it was a bit on the sarcastic side, but it was also a very good 'what you need to fix' letter. If I'd only known and had a thicker skin then. But I didn't. It took a long time for me to take my writing seriously again.
4th grade. Learning to write dialog. Got my story read in front of the class.
Tried to continue writing but I got confronted by other kids making fun of me. Then I decided I couldn't do it at all. Stopped writing until I got into graduate school. I was inspired by a professor who had dedicated his life to teaching about and researching on the Poet Robinson Jeffers. I got inspired to write again. Started writing poetry and accidentally got published one time.
I don't have a great story of someone taking me aside and giving me a message that caused me to become a writer... I've just never been able to leave it alone. Even during the times when I'm not writing, I read like crazy... and in my head I'm editing the story how I would have written it.
sarah:
I think so many of our early efforts were methods for figuring out our families and young lives.
E
I went to the same grade school from Kindergarten through 7th grade, so graduation from that school was a big deal. The entire class, probably 120 12 and 13 year olds, on bleachers on the stage of the school's auditorium. All I know is that I was on the front row, and awards were given. I know I thought nothing of it. Then the Principal got up to speak and give the English award, and said, "When I met with all the 7th grade teachers there was no doubt that this student was the one who deserved the award. We were all in agreement - because this student had exemplied excellence in every area of English beyond our wildest imagination." And then she said...AMY NATHAN.
I got a dictionary.
And I knew.
I was always creating long, long stories in my head, but I never thought of writing them down until there was a little contest. I thought, "cool, why not, those are spinning in my head all the time."
What I remember most about that period of time was toying with sentences. I would spend an hour on one sentence, changing a word, seeing what nuance each word choice did to the overall sentence, overall story.
I don't do that with words anymore, but I do play with plot, I guess.
Writing never occurred to me until the contest, but it always there. I just had no idea.
Erica, the first thought that comes to mind is watching old movies with my mom. I'd be so engaged in a story with Sandra Dee, Deborah Kerr, etc. The music, the dialogue just flowed through me. I had the same feeling when I finished my first novel. So, for me I experienced the feeling first, and captured it again in writing.
I'm always in awe by how early everyone realized they enjoyed writing, or wanted to be a writer.
I've always been a reader. To even consider *I* could try my hand at writing didn't occur to me until I was 39 years old (not THAT long ago, folks!!!) Now I'm hooked. And I'm reading more than ever. Amazing how that works!!
Congratulations for your daughter. I would've been crying up a storm!
**
(I sent you an email, and wanted to make sure it's not auto-directed into the spam filter)
:-)
Amy:
Wow . . . what a moment!
E
Spy:
I always love your story, how you entered a contest and won.
E
ladonna:
Baby Girl and I watch tons of old musicals.
E
Christine:
I didn't get it. :-(
erica@ericaorloff.com
?
Try erica323@comcast.net
E
Oh! Sorry, I didn't win. I just got honorable mention. It just got me going and published (although I didn't get paid for that one, so ...), and it inspired me to start writing because the theme captured my imagination.
Post a Comment
<< Home